HomeStoriesInvestigation
InvestigationINVESTIGATION 001

The Toxin Is in the Lake. Why Isn't It in the Water?

Harmful algal blooms in Lake Erie can produce cyanotoxins. Cleveland Water says it has monitored its source and finished water for cyanotoxins since 2010 — and has never detected them in finished drinking water. We want to understand exactly what stands between a bloom and someone's faucet.

Ainthavinit Media16 min read
Share

Every day, Northeast Ohio turns on the tap and draws from one of the largest freshwater systems on Earth. Lake Erie. It's also a lake facing a well-documented environmental problem.

Harmful algal blooms occur when cyanobacteria — sometimes called blue-green algae — grow rapidly under favorable conditions. Some cyanobacteria can produce toxins known as cyanotoxins, which can pose health risks to humans and animals through drinking-water and recreational exposure.

In Lake Erie, the problem is most severe in the western basin. EPA describes that portion of the lake as highly eutrophic, citing high phosphorus and chlorophyll concentrations and harmful algal blooms.

Cleveland sits farther east. Its drinking water comes from Lake Erie. And Cleveland Water reports something worth paying attention to: it has monitored source water and finished drinking water for cyanotoxins since 2010, and cyanotoxins have never been detected in its finished water.

"If cyanotoxin-producing organisms exist in the lake that supplies Cleveland's drinking water, what prevents those toxins from reaching someone's kitchen faucet?"

First, Cleveland Is Not Toledo

Any serious discussion about Lake Erie and harmful algal blooms needs to make this distinction. In 2014, a harmful algal bloom near Toledo's Lake Erie drinking-water intake resulted in roughly 500,000 customers being advised not to drink their tap water for nearly three days.

But Toledo and Cleveland draw water from different parts of Lake Erie. The western basin is relatively shallow, receives most of Lake Erie's phosphorus load and regularly experiences cyanobacterial blooms. The central basin is considerably deeper and experiences different environmental conditions.

That geographical difference matters. So do water depth, temperature, nutrient concentrations, tributaries and circulation. A major bloom in western Lake Erie does not automatically mean Cleveland's drinking-water source is experiencing identical conditions. But Lake Erie's basins aren't isolated bodies of water. They're connected.

EPA documents that water moves from the western basin into the central basin and eventually through the eastern basin toward Lake Ontario. EPA also notes that blooms originating in the western basin can move into the central basin. That's one reason monitoring matters.

What Exactly Are We Looking For?

The green material people associate with a harmful algal bloom isn't itself necessarily "the toxin." The organisms are cyanobacteria. Some cyanobacteria are capable of producing cyanotoxins. EPA identifies several cyanotoxins of concern in drinking-water sources, including microcystins, cylindrospermopsin, anatoxin-a and saxitoxin.

That distinction matters. Finding cyanobacteria doesn't automatically tell us how much toxin is present. And finding a toxin in source water doesn't automatically mean that toxin is reaching someone's faucet. Those are different questions.

Are toxin-producing cyanobacteria present near Cleveland's drinking-water intakes? Are cyanotoxins present in the raw Lake Erie water entering Cleveland's treatment plants? If they are present, at what concentrations? What happens to them during treatment? And ultimately: are cyanotoxins detectable in finished drinking water? Cleveland Water gives us an answer to the last question — it reports that cyanotoxins have never been detected in its finished water during monitoring dating back to 2010.

Raw Water vs. Finished Water

This may be the most important distinction in the investigation. Raw water is untreated source water entering the treatment process. Finished water is water that has gone through treatment before entering the distribution system. Finding a contaminant in raw water and finding the same contaminant in finished water mean very different things. A drinking-water treatment plant exists specifically to turn source water into drinking water. Treatment is the barrier.

EPA says conventional drinking-water treatment — including coagulation, sedimentation, filtration and chlorination — can generally remove intact cyanobacterial cells and low levels of cyanotoxins from source water. EPA also warns that severe blooms containing high concentrations of cyanobacteria and cyanotoxins can present greater treatment challenges.

What Stands Between the Lake and Your Faucet?

Cleveland doesn't simply pump Lake Erie water directly into people's homes. Water passes through treatment processes before entering the distribution system. When cyanobacteria are involved, the chemistry gets complicated. Cyanotoxins can exist inside intact cyanobacterial cells or outside the cells as dissolved toxins. That distinction changes how they must be treated.

EPA says coagulation, sedimentation and filtration can effectively remove intact cyanobacterial cells and the toxins contained inside them. Dissolved toxins can require different approaches. EPA reports that activated carbon can adsorb microcystins, while oxidants including ozone, potassium permanganate and — under appropriate conditions — free chlorine can be effective against certain cyanotoxins. Effectiveness varies depending on the toxin, treatment process and water conditions.

There's another complication. Treating cyanobacteria incorrectly can potentially rupture cells and release toxins into the water. EPA specifically warns that some pre-treatment oxidation can stress or break cyanobacterial cells, releasing cyanotoxins that had previously been contained inside them. In other words: removing algae and removing algal toxins aren't necessarily the same problem. That's why monitoring and treatment strategy matter.

The Statement We Want to Understand

Cleveland Water's published water-quality report states: "We have been monitoring for cyanotoxins in source and finished water since 2010. Cyanotoxins have never been detected in our finished water." That's a significant finding. And if the underlying records support it, it deserves to be reported as such.

But it also raises questions that a sentence in an annual water-quality report can't answer. How frequently has Cleveland tested since 2010? Which cyanotoxins were tested? What were the laboratory detection limits? How often have cyanotoxins been detected in raw Lake Erie water? What were the highest raw-water concentrations? Were there periods when cyanobacteria approached Cleveland's intakes but toxins remained undetected? Does sampling frequency increase during bloom conditions? What operational changes occur when conditions in Lake Erie deteriorate? How quickly would operators know if concentrations suddenly increased? Those are not accusations. They're questions. And they should have documented answers.

"If Cleveland's monitoring and treatment systems have successfully prevented cyanotoxins in Lake Erie from becoming a finished-drinking-water problem, we want to understand exactly how. Because documenting something that works is still investigative journalism."

Follow the Water

For this investigation, Ainthavinit Media wants to follow the same path the water follows: Lake Erie → Intake → Raw Water → Treatment → Finished Water → Distribution System → Home. At every point, we're asking a different question.

We'll seek Cleveland Water's historical cyanobacteria and cyanotoxin monitoring records, including raw- and finished-water results where available. We'll examine EPA and Ohio EPA records documenting harmful algal bloom conditions in Lake Erie. We'll investigate how Cleveland's treatment process responds to cyanobacteria and cyanotoxins. We'll ask the people operating and studying these systems what happens when conditions change. And we'll publish the records behind what we find.

This Investigation Isn't Starting With a Conclusion

There are two easy stories we could tell. The first is frightening: there are toxins in Lake Erie, therefore Cleveland's drinking water is dangerous. The evidence we've reviewed does not support making that claim. The second is reassuring: Cleveland Water hasn't detected cyanotoxins in finished drinking water, therefore there's nothing left to investigate. We don't think that's the right conclusion either.

What the evidence currently shows is more interesting. Lake Erie has a documented harmful algal bloom problem. Cyanotoxins produced during harmful algal blooms can pose human-health risks through drinking-water exposure. Cleveland Water has monitored source and finished water for cyanotoxins since 2010 and reports that none have ever been detected in its finished water. Those facts can all be true at the same time.

What We're Requesting

Ainthavinit Media will seek records documenting: cyanotoxin testing from 2010 through the present; raw-water and finished-water cyanotoxin results; cyanobacteria monitoring results; sampling locations and frequency; laboratory detection and reporting limits; highest historical raw-water concentrations; treatment changes associated with harmful algal bloom conditions; cyanotoxin response procedures; communications with Ohio EPA involving significant bloom events; and historical bloom conditions affecting or approaching Cleveland's drinking-water source.

The records we obtain will be added to our public Receipts collection as they're reviewed. If the records show Cleveland's treatment system has successfully protected finished drinking water from cyanotoxins for more than a decade, we'll show you the evidence. If they identify vulnerabilities, we'll show you those too. Either way, the conclusion should come after the evidence.

The Bigger Question

Northeast Ohio depends on Lake Erie. We drink from it. We recreate in it. Our rivers flow into it. Our wastewater eventually returns to it. And an enormous system of monitoring, treatment and infrastructure stands between that lake and the water coming from our faucets. Most people never see that system. They turn a handle. Water comes out. That's the part we're interested in.

Cleveland Water is telling us something remarkable: it has monitored for cyanotoxins in Lake Erie source water and finished drinking water since 2010 — and has never detected them in its finished water. Lake Erie still experiences harmful algal blooms capable of producing cyanotoxins. Somewhere between those two facts is a system of science, infrastructure, chemistry, monitoring and human decisions. We want to see it. We want to understand it. And we want to show you the evidence.

"The toxin can be in the lake. The question is why it isn't in the water."

This investigation is ongoing. Public records requests are being filed. If you have information about water quality issues in your community, we want to hear from you.

Share this story