Behind the Tap
A Northeast Ohio Water Investigation. We're not starting with an answer. We're starting with a question.
What's really in the water we drink? We're following Northeast Ohio's drinking water from Lake Erie and groundwater sources, through treatment plants and distribution systems, through aging service lines and household plumbing, and ultimately to the kitchen faucet. Cleveland Water's treatment plants may be doing their job. The real question is what happens after the water leaves them — and whether the gap between compliance and safety is something we can measure.
What We Found.
Lead exposure is primarily an infrastructure and property-level issue. Cleveland Water's latest compliance monitoring found 90% of sampled homes below 3.15 ppb — but lead service lines and lead plumbing remain in its service territory. How many families are still drinking through them, and how fast are they being replaced?
PFAS may be less of a Cleveland Water story than people expect — but the numbers need to be precise. Cleveland Water's UCMR5 monitoring tested 29 PFAS compounds across three rounds at four treatment plants in finished drinking water. 28 of 29 compounds were not detected at any plant in any round. One PFAS was detected at a very low level during one round. That's a finding worth reporting accurately. It also raises a better question: are there smaller Northeast Ohio systems or private wells where results look different?
Lake Erie is under significant environmental pressure. EPA data shows the western basin remains highly eutrophic, phosphorus targets have not been consistently achieved, and harmful algal blooms continue. Cleveland draws from the central basin — but it's the same interconnected lake.
Private wells in Northeast Ohio may be a serious underreported risk. In summer 2009, researchers tested 180 randomly selected private wells in two Northeast Ohio counties — an area characterized by intensive agriculture and a high concentration of dairy farms. Total coliform bacteria were found in 45% of the wells sampled, generic E. coli in 9%, and E. coli O157:H7 DNA was identified in 4% using real-time PCR. These findings describe the wells included in that study; they should not be interpreted as contamination rates for all private wells across Northeast Ohio. What would we find if we tested again in 2026?
We Show Our Work.
Cleveland Water's latest annual report documenting treatment plant performance, lead compliance monitoring results, UCMR5 PFAS monitoring across 29 compounds at four plants over three rounds, and cyanotoxin monitoring since 2010.
View SourceEPA Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement data on Lake Erie nutrient levels, harmful algal blooms, hypoxia, and the western basin's eutrophication status.
View SourceThe Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District routinely samples 15 Lake Erie shoreline locations and 75 sites across 18 streams, analyzing 30+ chemical and biological parameters.
View SourcePeer-reviewed study of 180 randomly selected private wells in two Northeast Ohio counties (summer 2009). Total coliform bacteria found in 45% of the wells sampled. These findings describe the study population — not all private wells across Northeast Ohio. The study's age is exactly why it justifies original 2026 testing.
View SourceOur own field study: testing water inside Northeast Ohio homes before and after treatment installation, across a range of housing ages, water sources, and neighborhoods. Goal: 25 families served.
Every document. Every dataset. Every source.
How We Got Here.
Investigation launched. Focus: the gap between treatment plant compliance and what actually reaches the tap.
Cleveland Water releases 2025 Water Quality Report. UCMR5 monitoring: 29 PFAS compounds tested across 3 rounds at 4 treatment plants. 28 compounds not detected at any plant in any round. One compound detected at a very low level in one round. Lead 90th percentile: 3.15 ppb. We start reading the fine print.
View SourceEPA Lake Erie data reviewed. Western basin eutrophication ongoing. Phosphorus targets not consistently met. HAB and cyanotoxin risk documented at the source.
25 Homes Water Project launched. Household water testing begins — lead, copper, bacteria, manganese, nitrates, and more — before any treatment is installed.
Investigation published. Findings ongoing. Private well testing study in development.
Compliance at the Plant Doesn't Mean Safety at the Tap
The water leaving Cleveland's treatment plants may meet every federal standard. What happens inside the pipes between the plant and your glass is a different question — and one worth asking.
The Toxin Is in the Lake. Why Isn't It in the Water?
Harmful algal blooms produce cyanotoxins in Lake Erie. Cleveland Water says it hasn't detected them in finished drinking water since monitoring began in 2010. We want to find out exactly what stands between a bloom and someone's faucet.
What Would We Find in Northeast Ohio's Private Wells Today?
In summer 2009, researchers tested 180 randomly selected private wells in two Northeast Ohio counties and found total coliform bacteria in 45% of the wells sampled. That study is old enough to justify a question: what would we find if we tested again today?
Know Something We Don't?
If you work in water utilities, municipal government, environmental regulation, or public health — or if you've had problems with your water — we want to hear from you. We take source confidentiality seriously.
Submit a TipThis Investigation Costs Money.
Lab testing, records requests, field reporting — independent investigative journalism doesn't fund itself. Your support keeps this investigation going.
Support the Work