HomeStoriesInvestigation
InvestigationBEHIND THE TAP

Lead Service Lines: How Many Are Still in the Ground?

Cleveland Water's compliance monitoring shows low lead levels at the homes it tests. But lead service lines and lead plumbing remain throughout its service territory. We're working to find out how much lead infrastructure is still in the ground, how quickly it's being removed — and how many households are still connected to it.

Ainthavinit Media16 min read
Share

There are two stories about lead in Cleveland's drinking water.

And both can be true.

The first is encouraging.

Cleveland Water's most recent published Lead and Copper Rule compliance monitoring found that 90% of samples were below 3.15 parts per billion of lead.

The samples were collected between June and September 2024 from 52 homes selected specifically because they met Tier 1 requirements involving lead service lines or lead plumbing. One of the 52 samples exceeded the then-federal lead action level of 15 parts per billion. Cleveland Water reported no lead violation.

That's significant.

But there's another story beneath the streets.

Cleveland Water's own infrastructure documents identify hundreds of thousands of city-owned and customer-owned service-line portions as lead, while the material of many other customer-owned lines remains unknown. Cleveland Water also acknowledges that some of its recorded classifications are estimates that will change as lines are inspected and replaced.

"Does Cleveland meet the lead standard? That's one question. How much lead infrastructure is still in the ground? That's another."

First, What Is a Lead Service Line?

The water main running underneath a street doesn't connect directly to someone's kitchen faucet.

A smaller pipe connects the water main to the building.

That's the service line.

EPA defines a service line as the portion of pipe connecting the water main or other distribution conduit to a building inlet.

Depending on the property and water system, responsibility for different portions of that line can be divided between the utility and property owner.

In Cleveland Water's system, records distinguish between city-owned and customer-owned portions.

Cleveland Water says lead was allowed for service connections one inch or smaller installed between 1856 and 1953, and the utility stopped using lead for new service connections beginning in 1954.

That means some of the infrastructure we're talking about isn't new.

Some of it has potentially been underground for generations.

Lead Doesn't Start at the Treatment Plant

Cleveland Water says its drinking water is lead-free when it leaves its treatment plants.

That's an important fact.

Lead can enter drinking water later when water comes into contact with plumbing materials containing lead.

EPA identifies lead service lines as the most significant source of lead in drinking water where they are present. Lead can also come from plumbing fixtures, faucets, solder and other plumbing materials.

That makes lead a perfect example of why Behind the Tap exists.

The treatment plant can produce water without lead. The water can meet regulatory requirements. And a lead pipe can still exist between the water main and someone's house.

Those facts aren't contradictory. They're different parts of the same system.

Cleveland Has Been Controlling the Risk

The presence of a lead service line does not mean every glass of water passing through it contains elevated lead.

Water chemistry matters. Corrosion control matters. How long water remains stagnant matters. The condition of the plumbing matters.

Cleveland Water says it has added orthophosphate since 1997. Orthophosphate forms a protective coating inside pipes and plumbing that reduces direct contact between water and metal and lowers the likelihood of lead dissolving into the water. Cleveland Water also controls the pH of finished water to reduce corrosiveness.

The compliance results suggest those measures have been effective.

Cleveland Water reports that its lead monitoring results have remained below the federal 15 ppb action level since 1997 and below 5 ppb at the 90th percentile for more than 15 years. Its most recent published result was 3.15 ppb at the 90th percentile.

That's worth reporting.

But corrosion control isn't the same thing as removing the pipe. And Cleveland Water knows that. It's replacing them.

So How Many Are Left?

This is where the numbers become complicated.

Cleveland Water Inventory — January 2024 Snapshot
~176,000City-owned service-line portions classified as lead
~194,000Customer-owned service-line portions classified as lead
~209,000Pre-1954 customer-owned connections of unknown material

These are inventory record counts, not a count of separate homes. City-owned and customer-owned portions can belong to the same service connection. Cleveland Water estimates ~95% of customer-owned lead connections will be attached to an existing city-owned lead service. The inventory also contains acknowledged inaccuracies.

But we need to be extremely careful with those numbers.

They do not mean 370,000 separate homes have lead service lines.

A single property can have a city-owned portion and customer-owned portion of the same service connection. Cleveland Water estimates that 95% of customer-owned lead connections or connections otherwise requiring replacement will be attached to an existing city-owned lead service.

So simply adding 176,000 and 194,000 would dramatically misrepresent the number of affected properties.

There's another complication.

Cleveland Water estimates that approximately 20% of city-owned connections currently recorded as lead may actually be copper because previous replacements haven't yet been reflected in the inventory.

And then there are the unknowns.

More Than 200,000 Customer-Side Lines Were Listed as Unknown

The same January 2025 document identified approximately 209,000 customer-owned connections that were one inch or smaller, installed before 1954 and recorded as being made from unknown material.

Those lines could be lead, galvanized steel requiring replacement, or another material.

Cleveland Water estimated from previous inspections that approximately 10% of those unknown customer-owned connections would ultimately prove to be lead or otherwise require replacement.

WHAT THESE NUMBERS DO — AND DON'T — TELL US

The ~176,000 and ~194,000 figures are inventory record counts for city-owned and customer-owned service-line portions respectively. They are not a count of separate homes. Cleveland Water estimates that ~95% of customer-owned lead connections will be attached to an existing city-owned lead service — meaning the two portions often belong to the same connection. The utility also acknowledges that ~20% of city-owned connections recorded as lead may actually be copper due to replacements not yet reflected in the inventory. The ~209,000 unknown figure represents pre-1954 customer-side connections whose material has not yet been verified — not 209,000 confirmed lead lines.

Cleveland Water says it updates its service-line tracking information as replacements and inspections occur. Its public Lead Awareness information also acknowledges that, as of October 2024, most customer-side service-line material remained unknown.

That's one reason we're interested in obtaining the underlying inventory.

This Is an Inventory Problem Before It's a Math Problem

At first glance, the question seems simple: how many lead service lines does Cleveland have?

But before that can be answered precisely, you have to know what every service line is made of. And Cleveland doesn't yet know that for every property.

EPA recognizes this as a national problem. Under its Lead and Copper Rule Improvements, public water systems are required to maintain service-line inventories categorizing lines as lead, non-lead, galvanized requiring replacement or unknown and continually update those inventories as better information becomes available.

Cleveland Water provides an interactive address-level map allowing customers to look up the recorded material of their service line and submit information when the customer-owned portion is unknown.

That creates an unusual opportunity. Instead of talking about lead infrastructure only as a citywide statistic, we may eventually be able to examine it property by property and neighborhood by neighborhood.

How Fast Are They Coming Out?

Cleveland Water isn't waiting for every unknown line to be identified before replacing known lead infrastructure.

Its proactive Lead Service Line Replacement Program began in 2023 using funding from the federal Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. Before that, Cleveland Water says it had already been replacing lead service lines during water-main repairs and replacement projects and completed replacement of lead and galvanized services at licensed childcare facilities in its service area in 2021–2022.

Cleveland Water's January 2025 project document estimated that the system would need to eliminate at least 4,000 connections per year to accomplish its stated 30-year systemwide elimination plan. For Years 1 and 2 of the program, Cleveland Water nominated projects intended to replace approximately 4,100 connections per year.

Then the target increased.

For Year 3, Cleveland Water proposed investigating service-line material at more than 10,000 locations and aimed to replace approximately 9,000 lead service lines. The document also cautioned that contractor and material capacity could limit completion of the entire proposed scope.

That's an important distinction too. A target isn't a completed replacement. So one of the records we want is simple: how many were actually replaced?

The Federal Rules Are Changing the Timeline

Cleveland's stated project documents describe a 30-year plan for eliminating lead service lines in its direct-service distribution area.

But federal requirements have changed.

EPA's final Lead and Copper Rule Improvements, issued in 2024, require water systems to fully replace lead and galvanized-requiring-replacement service lines under their control within 10 years after the rule's compliance date, with limited exceptions and provisions allowing deferred deadlines for certain systems with unusually large inventories.

EPA also specifies that a lead service line counts as fully replaced only when the entire length — both system and customer sides — is non-lead.

That creates another question for Cleveland: what does the new federal timeline mean for a system with this many lead and unknown service lines? That's something we're going to investigate rather than assume.

A Low Test Result Doesn't Make the Pipe Disappear

This may be the most important distinction in the story.

Cleveland's latest published compliance number is encouraging: 90% of the tested homes were below 3.15 ppb.

And these weren't simply random homes. Cleveland Water says its Tier 1 compliance samples come from single-family homes known to contain lead plumbing pipes and/or a city-owned or customer-owned lead service line.

That makes the low 90th-percentile result meaningful evidence that Cleveland's corrosion-control strategy is reducing lead exposure.

But it doesn't turn a lead service line into copper.

"Treatment manages the risk. Replacement removes the source. Those are different accomplishments. And both deserve to be measured."

We're Not Trying to Turn Every Lead Pipe Into a Contaminated Faucet

That would be inaccurate.

A home having a lead service line does not establish that the home's drinking water contains elevated lead. Likewise, a low systemwide compliance result does not establish that every individual faucet has the same lead concentration.

Lead exposure from drinking water depends on the interaction between the water and the plumbing it encounters.

That's why EPA's regulatory program includes both tap sampling and increasingly aggressive lead service-line identification and replacement requirements.

For Ainthavinit, those are two different questions: what does the water test show? And what infrastructure is the water traveling through? We want to document both.

What We Know

  • Cleveland Water says drinking water is lead-free when it leaves its treatment plants.
  • Cleveland has used orthophosphate corrosion control since 1997.
  • Cleveland Water's most recent published compliance monitoring found 90% of samples below 3.15 ppb, with one of 52 samples above the then-federal 15 ppb action level and no violation.
  • Cleveland Water's January 2025 project documentation reported approximately 176,000 city-owned and 194,000 customer-owned service-line portions classified as lead as of January 2024, while acknowledging that portions of the inventory were estimated or inaccurate.
  • That same document identified approximately 209,000 pre-1954 customer-owned connections of unknown material, while estimating that about 10% would ultimately prove to be lead or otherwise require replacement.
  • Cleveland Water is actively replacing lead service lines through a proactive program that began in 2023 using federal Bipartisan Infrastructure Law funding.

What We Don't Know

  • A verified 2026 count of individual properties still connected through a lead service line.
  • Exactly how many of the connections historically classified as lead have already been replaced but haven't yet been reflected in older inventory numbers.
  • How many of the remaining unknown customer-side lines will ultimately be identified as lead, galvanized requiring replacement or copper.
  • The exact number of full service connections replaced in each program year versus the number proposed or funded.
  • How the remaining lead infrastructure is distributed across every neighborhood and municipality in Cleveland Water's service territory.
  • What Cleveland's 30-year planning framework will look like under EPA's newer federal replacement requirements.

What We're Requesting

Records We're Requesting
01Cleveland Water's current service-line inventory — known lead, galvanized-requiring-replacement, unknown materials, full connections versus individual city/customer portions
02Lead service lines replaced by year — replacements completed versus replacements proposed
03Replacements by municipality, neighborhood or ZIP code where available
04Current replacement contracts, project expenditures, federal and state funding
05Current replacement-rate projections and updated elimination timelines
06Methodology used to classify service-line materials
07Records documenting changes from unknown or lead classifications to verified copper
08Cleveland's plans for complying with the Lead and Copper Rule Improvements

Where the data already exists electronically, we'll request it in machine-readable form. Then we'll compare what was planned with what actually happened.

And We'll Take It to the Houses

This is where the infrastructure investigation connects directly to Behind the Tap.

For participating homes, we can document: what does Cleveland Water's inventory say the service line is made of? What can we physically verify at the property? How old is the home? What plumbing materials exist inside? What does an independent point-of-use water sample show?

That gives us something a citywide statistic can't: the ability to put the record, the pipe and the water sample next to each other.

"Maybe they tell the same story. Maybe they don't. Either result matters."

The Bigger Question

A lead service line can spend decades underground. You don't see it when you walk into the kitchen. You don't see it when you turn on the faucet. And if corrosion control is working properly, the water traveling through it may still produce low lead results.

That's good.

But underneath the property, the pipe is still lead.

Cleveland Water's own records show a system actively working to remove that legacy infrastructure. They also show how difficult the job is. Hundreds of thousands of service-line records. Unknown materials. Old records. Previously replaced lines that may not yet be reflected accurately. Customer-side plumbing. City-side plumbing. Funding. Contractors. Excavation. And thousands of replacements.

So we're not beginning this investigation by saying Cleveland's lead-control program isn't working. The compliance numbers give us evidence that it is working.

We're asking the next question.

"If removing the lead pipe is the ultimate solution, how much is still down there? How many properties remain connected? Where are they? How quickly are the lines disappearing? And how long will it actually take until the answer is: none."

This investigation is underway. As records arrive, Ainthavinit Media will publish the service-line data, replacement numbers, public-record responses, field documentation and source material behind this investigation.

Share this story